There are many
different methods of storytelling: novels, films, comics, television, oral,
even the news can be considered storytelling. However, one method of
storytelling that has become quite underrated is the musical. Throughout
history, the musical has actually been a prominent way to tell stories. Just
think of the theaters of ancient Greece when plays such as Oedipus the King and Antigone
would tell stories and legends of the Greek culture. These plays were the
earliest musicals—they utilized a chorus that sang refrains to the characters
in the performance and had all the other components of a musical we still use
today.
The
musical has evolved from the ancient Greek plays to the Broadway hits that
exist today. When you think about it, the musical has been around longer than
the novel (which came around in the 17th or 18th century)
which is interesting since most people regard books and novels as the primary
method of storytelling today. There are several reasons the novel has survived
this long. First of all, musicals have all the components that make a good
story just like movies and books. They have relatable characters, vivid
scenery, and a plot that includes exposition, rising action, climax, falling
action, and a conclusion. This is just the skeleton of any basic story though. The
reason musicals didn’t crumble though is not what makes them similar to other
story telling methods—it’s what sets them apart. Musicals are able to convey
profound emotion and stories in two to three hour periods, while books convey
this emotion in hundreds of pages. People have short attention spans unfortunately
and if they can experience a story in two hours rather than the two days it
would take them to read a book, they’re most likely going to pick the two hour
option—the musical. Unfortunately due to cost and transportation issues,
musicals are less popular than movies. Yet they can often convey the type of insightful
emotion seen in books better than movies since musicals use the component of
song. Songs are powerful tools in the storytelling world because they can fit a
world of emotion and character development in a three to five minute time span.
In a musical, relatable lyrics joined with the performer’s intonation and the excitement
in the music makes for a powerful combination. In one song, you can learn the
context of a scene, a character’s backstory, the love between two characters,
and more. For example, think of the Disney movie-musicals you watched as a kid.
In Beauty and the Beast, the opening song gives the audience so much
information in a short period of time. The scene is set: the movie takes place
in a tiny French village where everybody knows everybody. The characters are
established: we learn that Belle is the most beautiful girl in town, loves to
read, and is thought to be weird; Gaston is arrogant, vain, and self-centered;
and the village people are old-fashioned, normal people who live a routine
life. The song also sets up the general plot of the story; it’s the ‘exposition’:
Belle is sick of this village life and wants more from life; Gaston plans to
marry her, etc. etc. Or how about Belle’s reprise of the opening song, the
audience learns how she desperately wants to be free and get out of her little
village and how she yearns for somebody to understand her and not think she’s
strange. Through the song you can feel the desperation and passion in her
voice. Other storytelling methods don’t have this tool. Musicals allow the
audience to understand the context of the story and to empathize with the
characters through song.
Another
reason musicals are unique is the fact that they’re live. When you read a book
or watch a movie over and over again, the story becomes predictable. Eventually,
the audience doesn’t become active participants in the story. But with
musicals, the audience members always have to be active participants. With live
events, there’s an element of unpredictability that keeps the audience on their
feet. There’s the possibility actors
could drop a line and have to improvise, or a prop or piece of scenery wouldn’t
make it out on stage on time, or the company of the show could plan to do
something different for a special show or something. Point is, is that when you
go see a musical, there’s always the possibility that the story can be changed.
Unpredictability is exciting. It keeps the audience alert and at the ready.
Sometimes, audience members even like it when an actor drops a line—it’s like a
little game of who knows the show better, whether you can catch the line
dropped or not.
All
in all, musicals are a unique way of storytelling that unfortunately many
people glance over when they want a story. Most people gravitate towards books
and movies as their storytelling method of choice, but the musical allows for a
story to be told in a unique way, through song and dance as well as dialogue.
Funny enough, many hit Broadway musicals were based on books. Wicked, Les Miserables, Rent, Matilda, the
Color Purple, Mame…all of these famous musicals were based on a book. Musicals
are a new way of looking at a story and allow us to participate actively in the
story through live shows, music, and dance. Like the playwright Arthur Miller
said, “the theater is so endlessly fascinating is because it’s so accidental.
It’s so much like life.” Musicals are a
method of storytelling that are just as good as more popular methods of
storytelling. So go to the theater, see your school’s spring musical, watch Les
Miz when it comes on TV, and experience the magic of a musical.
P.S. And just for fun, here's a parody of the song 'Belle' from Beauty and the Beast.

I think the other reason movies have it over musicals is because musicals to some people are "corny, unrealistic, and sing songy." I suppose it has to do with the type of acting that goes into it and how some of the songs sound, musicals have evolved from making tin pan alley songs popular in the early 1900s (since that was how people's music became famous before recording means and radio). Today, theatrical music has evolved into an acquired taste. Also some musicals plotlines don't appeal to the general public since you can't throw in the Michael Bay explosions and sex scenes people are obsessed with. They were more popular back when it was the only form of entertainment before movies, it's kind of a shame really but it's how it happened. Of course this is coming form someone who much prefers musicals like 42nd street to Newsies for example.
ReplyDeleteI agree. I think it is hard to appeal to audiences today because we are so used to the kind of special effects and 'movie magic' used in films today, so when people see a musical, the average Joe is disappointed. I think that as a storytelling method though, they are underestimated as a storyteling method, but it is true that storytelling is evolving as technology evolves which could be either good or bad for the musical.
DeleteI tend to like musicals that are campy, or intentionally ridiculous, just because they are so self-aware. I think camp in a musical is the writer's, director's, and actors' way of telling us that, yes, they know that it is nothing like real life, people don't break out in song in the real world, get over it. I think a lot of people dismiss musicals as romantic and unrealistic, but they fail to realize that there are a lot of musicals that don't take themselves too seriously. Instead, they choose musical numbers and exaggerated aesthetics to tell a story that is intended to amuse people.
ReplyDeleteThat being said, the ones that DO take themselves seriously (i.e. Les Mis) are often spectacular feats of dramatic and musical genius that I don't feel like elaborating upon in this comment.
Although I haven't seen many musicals in my life, I enjoy every minute of them. I agree with what you said about "In a musical, relatable lyrics joined with the performer’s intonation and the excitement in the music makes for a powerful combination". Beauty and the Beast was honestly my favorite movie as a little kid. The songs truly make the film and like you said, they are capable of summing up a part of the story in a fun and entertaining way. Plus, the older I get, the more I understand the songs in these films. My most recent musical favorite was Les Miserables. I absolutely LOVED the movie and hope that I will be able to see it as a musical in "real life" someday. Many people did not get how one movie could be all song but sometimes movies with songs are the best ones. Basically all of the Disney princess films contain songs and are enjoyed by people of all ages. Maybe that is the reason these films will never go out of style...
ReplyDelete